CLAT Admit Card 2025 (Out): Exam Hall Ticket Download, Exam Instructions, Timings

General Principles of Criminal Law for CLAT - Practice Questions & MCQ

Edited By admin | Updated on Sep 25, 2023 25:47 PM | #CLAT

Quick Facts

  • 9 Questions around this concept.

Solve by difficulty

Read the following passage and answer the questions.

It is a well-established principle of criminal law that a person is solely accountable for crimes committed by himself and not for conduct committed by others. In other words, the main concept of criminal culpability is that the individual who commits an offence bears the primary responsibility, and only that person may be declared guilty and punished in line with the law. Opposing this general rule, Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) states that when criminal conduct is committed by numerous people in pursuit of a ‘common intention’, each of them is accountable for the crime in the same way as if it were committed by him alone. This clause, which establishes a principle of shared accountability in the commission of a criminal act, is an exception to a fundamental canon of criminal law. The core of joint culpability is found in the existence of a shared goal energizing the accused, which leads to the commission of a criminal act in pursuit of that intention.

IPC provides for various forms of group liabilities e.g. group liability under section 34 in the form of a rule of evidence making each member of the group liable for the final act if he has in any manner participated in action in furtherance of the common intention of all the members of the group irrespective of his individual contribution which may have been very small. Further, group liability under section 149 is envisaged making the members of the unlawful assembly vicariously liable for the criminal act which is in furtherance of the common object or what members of the unlawful assembly ought to have known is likely to be committed in given circumstances besides making each of them liable for punishment for being a member of an unlawful assembly.

Question: Several men assaulted a person with rods. The person ran, but another person caught him, and hand him over to the men beating him. What is the liability of the person who caught hold of the person running?

 

A committed theft in the house of B. When A committed theft, it was not a crime as per the country's legal system. The next day, legislature declares theft as a crime punishable by death.Will A be liable for theft? 

A committed murder of B. C, the son of B filed a case in court and the court convited A for murder. A was sentenced to 20 years life sentence. After 20 years when A was released, C again filed a case and the court convicted A for 20 years of life sentence again. Is court right in making this decision? 

Concepts Covered - 1

General Principles of Criminal Law

Presumption of Innocence:

  • Principle: The foundation of the criminal justice system rests on the presumption of innocence. This legal doctrine dictates that any person accused of a crime is considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
  • Significance: By placing the burden of proof on the prosecution, this principle safeguards individuals from unjust accusations and ensures that guilt is established only when there is convincing evidence that leaves no reasonable doubt.
  • Example: In a theft case, the accused is protected by the presumption of innocence until the prosecution provides compelling evidence that unequivocally establishes their guilt. This principle ensures a fair trial and prevents premature judgments.

Principle of Proportionality:

  • Principle: The principle of proportionality in criminal law mandates that the punishment for a crime should be proportional to the severity of the offense committed.
  • Significance: This principle prevents arbitrary and unjust sentencing, maintaining a balance between the gravity of the crime and the punishment imposed. It ensures that society's sense of justice is upheld and that punishments neither exceed nor fall short of what is justifiable.
  • Example: If an individual is found guilty of a white-collar crime involving substantial financial loss, a proportional punishment might involve fines and restitution rather than an excessively harsh prison sentence, thereby aligning the penalty with the offense.

Mens Rea and Actus Reus:

  • Principle: The interaction of Mens Rea (guilty mind) and Actus Reus (guilty act) forms a crucial aspect of criminal law. Mens Rea refers to the mental intent or state of mind required to commit a crime, while Actus Reus encompasses the physical actions that constitute the criminal offense.
  • Significance: Both principles must coexist for criminal liability to be established. Mens Rea ensures that a person's mental state aligns with the prohibited act they committed, while Actus Reus ensures that the actual commission of the act occurred.
  • Example: In a case of premeditated murder, Mens Rea involves a deliberate intent to cause death, and Actus Reus encompasses the physical act of killing. Both elements must be present for a conviction to be just.

Legal Certainty and Clarity:

  • Principle: The principle of legal certainty asserts that criminal laws should be clear, precise, and easily understood by both legal professionals and the general public.
  • Significance: Clarity in criminal laws helps individuals understand what actions are prohibited, ensuring that everyone is aware of the boundaries of legal conduct. It prevents arbitrary enforcement and promotes equal application of the law.
  • Example: A law that defines theft as "intentional taking of another person's property without consent and with the intent to permanently deprive the owner" provides clear guidance, reducing confusion and potential misinterpretations.

Conclusion

  • Embodying fairness, just punishment, clarity, and adherence to justice.
  • Grasping these principles empowers critical case analysis and judicious legal application.
  • Encompasses presumption of innocence, proportionality, Mens Rea and Actus Reus, and legal clarity.
  • These principles serve as the moral compass guiding the legal landscape.
  • Mastering General Principles of Criminal Law equips legal thinkers to adeptly navigate the intricate intricacies of the legal world, fostering a system of justice that respects fundamental human rights and ensures the proper administration of law.

"Stay in the loop. Receive exam news, study resources, and expert advice!"

Get Answer to all your questions

Back to top