The Allahabad High Court has ordered the Consortium of NLUs to revise the CLAT 2026 merit list in an answer key dispute. On February 3, 2026, a single bench judge of Justice Vivek Saran J, the Allahabad HC delivered its judgment in the legal battle between Avneesh Gupta (Minor) vs. Consortium of National Law Universities. In his petition, Gupta alleged that the Consortium of NLUs did not consider three of his objections in the CLAT 2026 final answer key. Meanwhile, the Consortium of NLUs argued that its headquarters were situated in Karnataka, and this does not come under the Allahabad HC’s jurisdiction. On the other hand, the Allahabad HC noted that the exam was held in Ghaziabad and the court held its jurisdiction under Article 26.
Category | Details from Judgment |
Case Title | Avneesh Gupta (Minor) vs. Consortium of National Law Universities |
Court | High Court of Judicature at Allahabad |
Judgment Delivered On | February 3, 2026 |
Writ Petition No. | WRIT-C No. 45517 of 2025 |
Judicial Officer | Hon’ble Vivek Saran, J. |
Petitioner | Avneesh Gupta (Minor) |
Respondent | Consortium of National Law Universities |
Petitioner’s Counsel | In Person |
Respondent’s Counsel | Avneesh Tripathi |
Attempt Free Official Practice Test & Solutions and Ace the CLAT Exam 2026
In his petition to the Allahabad HC, petitioner Avneesh Gupta sought relief described in five points. The petitioner sought relief, alleging that the Consortium of NLUs did not consider three objections he filed in the final answer key. Here are the reliefs that the petitioner sought from the Allahabad HC:
Writ directing the respondent to withdraw the incorrect questions in the CLAT exam 2026 .
Award appropriate marks for those questions and modify the petitioner’s rank in the CLAT 2026 merit list.
Issue a writ to review objections properly.
Issue direction to publish the corrected merit list and rank list.
Recalculate the petitioner’s marks as per the corrected answer key.
The petitioner, Avneesh Gupta, argued that the rejection of three of his objections was invalid. Gupta argued that despite the Expert Committee supporting his answers, the final answer key did not reflect the corrections. This action of the Consortium of the NLUs led to his rank going down and hampered his admission chances.
While the case was being heard in the Allahabad HC, both parties argued through their respective counsels. The Consortium of NLUs initially argued that since its headquarters were located in Karnataka, this case did not come under the jurisdiction of the Allahabad HC. The Allahabad HC under Article 26 came under its jurisdiction since the exam was held in Ghaziabad. Furthermore, the Consortium argued that the valuation and correctness of questions lie within the expert domain, and the court should not re-evaluate exam answers. The High Court agreed to this, but said there was a procedural infirmity.
Get the CLAT UG previous year question papers here
The following questions were objected to by the petitioner, and the expert committee made the following observations:
Question No. (Booklet-C) | Expert Committee Opinion | Oversight Committee Decision |
6 | Option ‘B’ is correct | Not altered |
9 | Both options ‘B’ & ‘D’ correct | Oversight Committee retained only ‘B’ without reasons |
13 | Option ‘C’ is correct | Not altered |
In its judgment, the Allahabad HC directed the Consortium of NLUs to revise the CLAT 2026 merit list. The detailed judgment read, “In such view of the matter, the respondent directed to revise the merit list by awarding marks against question no. 9 of booklet-C (corresponding to question no. 91 of booklet-A) and to all other questions which correspond to the same in.”
“In absence of any reason been given for overruling the decision of the Expert Committee by the Oversight Committee with respect to question no. 91 of booklet-A (correspond to question no. 9 of bookletC), the same is hereby quashed and the answers of the Expert Committee are sustained.”
The court further ordered that no changes be made in the admissions already done. However, the Consortium of NLUs must consider the revised merit list for further admission process.
On Question asked by student community
Hello Student,
You can refer to the following Careers360 resources to study Law of Contracts for CLAT Legal Reasoning:
Contract Law – Chapter-wise Study Material:
https://www.careers360.com/legal-studies/contract-law-chapter-pge
Contract Law and Tort Basics for CLAT 2027:
https://law.careers360.com/articles/contract-law-and-tort-basics-for-clat-2027-legal-reasoning
Hello Lavina,
For CLAT 2028 preparation, students should choose an online coaching programme that offers comprehensive study material, regular mock tests, current affairs updates, doubt-solving sessions and expert guidance. Compare course features, faculty experience and student reviews before selecting a coaching programme.
Hello Miruthula,
For CLAT PG 2027, you need to focus on the core subjects of your LLB curriculum, particularly the following:
Constitutional Law
Jurisprudence
Administrative Law
Law of Contract
Law of Torts
Family Law
Criminal Law
Property Law
Company Law
Public International Law
Tax Law
Environmental Law
Labour and Industrial
Hello Student,
The full form of the CLAT exam is the Common Law Admission Test. You can check the link related to the CLAT exam
https://law.careers360.com/articles/what-is-clat-full-form-all-about-nlus-entrance-exam
Hello Student,
Here are the Careers360 CLAT 2027 Mock Test Resources for your exam preparation.
1. Online CLAT Mock Test
2. CLAT Mock Tests and Solutions
Ranked #18 amongst Institutions in India by NIRF | Get Upto 100% Scholarships | Spot Admissions via CUET
NAAC A++ Approved | Curriculum Aligned with BCI & UGC
UG Scholar's Round Deadline: 1st Dec'26 | Earn upto 50% merit Scholarship + 10% for top performers | Highest CTC 18 LPA
Grade 'A+' Accredited by NAAC | Ranked 33rd in India by NIRF
Moot Court | Mock trials | Legal Aid Clinic | Recruiting Partners: FICCI, TCS, Adani, Trilegal, and many others
NAAC A++ Accredited | Avail up to 100% scholarship via MRNAT-Manav Rachna National Aptitude Test